The `nwidart/laravel-modules` package is a re-published, re-organised, and maintained version of the `pingpong/modules` package. Here are the key differences and similarities:
Differences:
1. Maintenance: `nwidart/laravel-modules` is actively maintained and updated, whereas `pingpong/modules` is no longer maintained.2. Compatibility: `nwidart/laravel-modules` supports Laravel 5.4 to 11, while `pingpong/modules` was primarily designed for Laravel 5.4 to 5.8.
3. Tests: `nwidart/laravel-modules` includes tests, which is a significant addition compared to `pingpong/modules`.
4. Documentation: `nwidart/laravel-modules` has more comprehensive documentation and guides on how to use the package effectively.
Similarities:
1. Modular Structure: Both packages provide a structured way to organize your Laravel application into smaller, reusable modules.2. Views, Controllers, and Models: Both packages include views, controllers, and models within each module.
3. Autoloading: Both packages require manual autoloading of module classes using `composer dump-autoload`.
4. Installation: Both packages can be installed via Composer and require manual configuration of the module paths.
5. Usage: Both packages provide commands to generate modules, models, controllers, and other necessary files.
Conclusion:
`nwidart/laravel-modules` is a more comprehensive and actively maintained version of `pingpong/modules`. It supports a broader range of Laravel versions and includes tests, making it a better choice for developers looking for a robust module management system.Citations:
[1] https://nwidart.com/laravel-modules/v3/introduction
[2] https://nwidart.com/laravel-modules/v1/introduction
[3] https://github.com/nWidart/laravel-modules
[4] https://laravel-news.com/package/nwidart-laravel-modules
[5] https://blog.codehunger.in/how-to-create-custom-module-in-laravel-9/