How does the Versa 4's GPS accuracy compare to the Garmin Venu Sq 2

Fitbit Versa 4 GPS Accuracy

- General Performance: The Versa 4 has built-in GPS, allowing users to track workouts without needing their phone nearby. However, some users have reported issues with GPS accuracy, citing discrepancies in distance and elevation tracking. The placement of the GPS antenna at the back of the device is believed to contribute to these inaccuracies, as it may not provide a clear line of sight to satellites[1][9].
- User Experiences: Some users have noted significant discrepancies in GPS tracking, with the watch sometimes recording incorrect distances or stopping mid-workout. For instance, one user reported a 30% overestimation of mileage during walks[9].
- Comparison to Other Devices: While the Versa 4 is generally praised for its ease of use and streamlined interface, its GPS accuracy can be inconsistent compared to other devices like Garmin watches[4][7].

Garmin Venu Sq 2 GPS Accuracy

- General Performance: The Garmin Venu Sq 2 features an upgraded GPS chipset similar to those in Garmin's high-end models like the Fenix 7. This results in generally reliable GPS performance, although it may take a couple of minutes to achieve a lock in new areas[2][8].
- User Experiences: Some users have noted that the Venu Sq 2 can underreport distances compared to other GPS devices. For example, it might record a 6km run as 500 meters shorter than actual[5].
- Comparison to Other Devices: The Venu Sq 2's GPS accuracy is often compared favorably to other mid-range smartwatches, though it may not match the precision of Garmin's top-tier models like the Fenix series[2][8].

Key Differences

- Design and Antenna Placement: The Versa 4's GPS antenna placement at the back of the device can lead to poor signal reception, while the Venu Sq 2's design does not have similar issues reported.
- GPS Chipset: The Venu Sq 2 uses a more advanced GPS chipset, which generally provides better performance and accuracy compared to the Versa 4.
- User Needs: The choice between these devices may depend on whether you prioritize detailed fitness tracking and robust GPS (Garmin Venu Sq 2) or a more streamlined, user-friendly experience (Fitbit Versa 4)[6].

In summary, while both devices have their strengths and weaknesses, the Garmin Venu Sq 2 tends to offer more reliable GPS performance, especially in terms of distance accuracy, although it may have some initial lock-in delays. The Fitbit Versa 4, on the other hand, is more suited for casual users who prioritize ease of use and may not require precise GPS tracking for every workout.