How does the MacBook Pro M4's fan noise compare to the 16-inch MacBook Pro with Intel Core i9 during intense video editing

MacBook Pro M4

The MacBook Pro M4 models, including both the Pro and Max versions, generally operate quietly during light tasks like browsing or streaming. However, when subjected to intense tasks such as video editing, the fans can become noticeable. The M4 Max, in particular, tends to run warmer and may not engage its fans as aggressively as other models, which can lead to a quieter operation under heavy loads compared to some other configurations[1][5]. The M4 Pro models, especially the 14-inch versions, can be louder due to their single-fan design, which must work harder to cool the system[5].

16-inch MacBook Pro with Intel Core i9

The Intel Core i9 MacBook Pros are known for their powerful performance but also for generating significant heat, which requires more aggressive cooling. As a result, the fans in these models can be quite loud, especially during intense tasks like video editing. The dual-fan setup helps dissipate heat more effectively but often at the cost of increased noise levels compared to the newer Apple Silicon models.

Comparison

In general, the Intel Core i9 MacBook Pro tends to be louder than the M4 models during intense tasks due to its more powerful and heat-intensive processor. The M4 models, particularly the M4 Max, offer a balance between performance and noise, often staying quieter under heavy loads compared to their Intel counterparts. However, the M4 Pro models, especially those with a single fan, can be louder than the M4 Max but still generally quieter than the Intel i9 models[1][2][5].

Overall, while both models can produce noticeable fan noise during intense video editing, the M4 models tend to be quieter and more efficient in managing heat and noise compared to the older Intel-based MacBook Pros.