When comparing the Huawei Watch Ultimate and the Fitbit Versa for tracking daily activities, several factors come into play, including GPS accuracy, heart rate monitoring, sleep tracking, and overall fitness features.
GPS Accuracy
- Huawei Watch Ultimate: This watch features a dual-band multi-system GNSS, which allows it to receive signals from five different satellite systems, enhancing its GPS accuracy. It has been noted to perform well in various environments, often matching the accuracy of high-end GPS devices like Garmin models[1][4]. The GPS accuracy is generally excellent, with an average total distance difference of under 2% per run compared to control devices[9].- Fitbit Versa: While Fitbit devices are generally reliable for distance tracking, they may not match the precision of high-end GPS watches. Users have reported discrepancies in mileage tracking, with some instances showing less accuracy compared to other devices like Samsung smartwatches[5].
Heart Rate Monitoring
- Huawei Watch Ultimate: Huawei wearables are known for their accurate heart rate tracking, though they might struggle with capturing extreme peaks during high-intensity interval training (HIIT), similar to other smartwatches[7].- Fitbit Versa: Fitbit devices have been shown to underestimate heart rate by about 9.3 beats per minute during exercise[3]. Some users have reported significant inaccuracies, especially during intense activities[2].
Sleep Tracking
- Huawei Watch Ultimate: Huawei watches, including the Watch Ultimate, are praised for their accurate sleep tracking capabilities. Users can analyze their sleep patterns in detail using the Huawei Health app[1].- Fitbit Versa: Fitbit devices are generally good at tracking sleep, though they can overestimate total sleep time by up to 67 minutes and have varying accuracy for different stages of sleep[3].
Overall Fitness Features
- Huawei Watch Ultimate: Offers a wide range of workout modes, including Expedition Mode, which is excellent for trail running and outdoor activities. It provides detailed fitness data like VO2 Max and aerobic/anaerobic stress[4].- Fitbit Versa: Provides a variety of fitness tracking features, including step count and caloric expenditure, though these can be less accurate compared to more specialized fitness watches[6].
In summary, the Huawei Watch Ultimate tends to offer more precise GPS tracking and heart rate monitoring compared to the Fitbit Versa. However, both devices have their strengths in different areas, with Fitbit being more accessible for general fitness tracking and Huawei excelling in advanced outdoor and fitness features.
Citations:
[1] https://www.t3.com/reviews/huawei-watch-ultimate-review
[2] https://www.reddit.com/r/fitbit/comments/160rgex/how_accurate_is_fitbit_i_cant_find_a_straight/
[3] https://www.aim7.com/blog/smartwatch-wearable-technology-accuracy
[4] https://www.techradar.com/reviews/huawei-watch-ultimate
[5] https://community.fitbit.com/t5/Other-Versa-Smartwatches/Versa-mileage-tracked-accuracy/td-p/2864976
[6] https://versus.com/en/fitbit-versa-vs-huawei-watch-gt
[7] https://www.androidauthority.com/huawei-watch-ultimate-review-3335995/
[8] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6107736/
[9] https://www.expertreviews.co.uk/smartwatches/1418577/huawei-watch-ultimate-review