When comparing the heart rate monitoring capabilities of the Huawei Watch Ultimate and Garmin watches, several notable differences emerge:
1. Sensor Technology and Accuracy:
- Huawei Watch Ultimate: It features Huawei's TruSeen 5.0+ heart rate sensor, which is designed to provide real-time heart rate monitoring. The watch uses eight photoelectric sensors, two groups of light sources, and an upgraded AI algorithm to enhance accuracy, especially during strenuous workouts[1][4]. Some users report that Huawei's heart rate sensors are superior to Garmin's in certain scenarios, such as capturing heart rate spikes during intense activities[3].
- Garmin Watches: Garmin watches also offer continuous heart rate monitoring and are compatible with both wrist-based and chest heart rate monitors. The wrist-based sensor is reliable, but for more precise readings, especially during intense workouts, pairing with a chest strap is recommended[2][5].
2. ECG and Advanced Health Features:
- Huawei Watch Ultimate: Offers ECG measurement support, which can detect premature heartbeats and alert users to possible heart conditions. It also includes features like arterial stiffness detection, which is not commonly found in many smartwatches[1][4].
- Garmin Watches: Some Garmin models, like those with FDA-cleared EKG features, can detect AFib and provide abnormal heart rate alerts. However, these features might require active selection and may not be as comprehensive as Huawei's offerings in terms of unique health metrics like arterial stiffness[5][8].
3. Continuous Monitoring and Alerts:
- Huawei Watch Ultimate: Continuously monitors heart rate and sends alerts for abnormal readings, providing ongoing health insights[12].
- Garmin Watches: Also offers continuous heart rate monitoring and alerts for abnormal heart rates, but the specific features and alerts may vary by model[5].
4. Integration and Compatibility:
- Huawei Watch Ultimate: Works seamlessly with Huawei's ecosystem but has limited app support compared to Garmin's broader compatibility with various health and fitness apps[10].
- Garmin Watches: Generally offers better integration with a wide range of fitness apps and devices, enhancing its utility for athletes and fitness enthusiasts[5].
In summary, while both the Huawei Watch Ultimate and Garmin watches provide robust heart rate monitoring, Huawei's advanced sensor technology and unique health features like arterial stiffness detection set it apart. Garmin, however, excels in app compatibility and integration with a broader fitness ecosystem.
Citations:
[1] https://www.expertreviews.co.uk/smartwatches/1418577/huawei-watch-ultimate-review
[2] https://www8.garmin.com/manuals/webhelp/GUID-9D99A9D4-467A-4F1A-A0EA-023184FEA3DD/EN-US/GUID-BDCC2C12-1D33-45DB-967B-4313BBA83BC9.html
[3] https://www.reddit.com/r/HuaweiWatchGT/comments/16va37z/why_choose_huaweii_instead_of_garmin/
[4] https://www.phonearena.com/reviews/huawei-watch-ultimate-review_id5760
[5] https://www.theverge.com/23691498/best-garmin-smartwatch-fitness-tracker-wearables
[6] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fcv5539sdQg
[7] https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidphelan/2023/05/25/forget-apple-watch-huawei-watch-ultimate-beats-apple-to-game-changing-new-features/
[8] https://www.reddit.com/r/GarminWatches/comments/1dp315w/help_choosing_garmin_watch_with_the_best_heart/
[9] https://lifehacker.com/health/best-fitness-tracker-measure-hrv
[10] https://www.androidauthority.com/huawei-watch-ultimate-review-3335995/
[11] https://www.hodinky-365.com/blog/duel-garmin-venu-2s-vs-huawei-watch-gt-3-42-mm-x33846
[12] https://consumer.huawei.com/uk/wearables/watch-ultimate/