Home Arrow Icon Knowledge base Arrow Icon Global Arrow Icon Can using ->get() instead of ->all() affect the randomness of the recycle method


Can using ->get() instead of ->all() affect the randomness of the recycle method


Using `->get()` instead of `->all()` can indeed affect the randomness of the `recycle` method in Laravel factories.

Explanation

1. Behavior of `->all()` vs. `->get()`:
- The `->all()` method retrieves all records from the database as a collection, but it may not always instantiate the collection in a way that supports random selection effectively.
- The `->get()` method, on the other hand, retrieves models and returns them as a collection that is more suitable for operations like random selection.

2. Reported Issues:
- Users have reported that using `->all()` with the `recycle` method often results in the last model in the collection being consistently returned, rather than a random model. This was highlighted in discussions where developers expected a random selection but encountered the same model repeatedly when using `->all()` [1].

3. Recommendation:
- Switching to `->get()` when retrieving models for recycling can help ensure that the collection behaves as expected, allowing the `recycle` method to select a random model from the provided collection. This is particularly relevant for ensuring that the `age_group_marketplace_id` column, for example, is populated with different random values as intended.

Conclusion

In summary, using `->get()` instead of `->all()` can improve the randomness of model selection when utilizing the `recycle` method in Laravel factories. If you are experiencing issues with consistent returns of the last model, it is advisable to implement this change.

Citations:
[1] https://stackoverflow.com/questions/74384052/laravel-factory-recycle-method-not-randomize-input-collection
[2] https://stackoverflow.com/questions/tagged/laravel-factory?tab=Newest
[3] https://stackoverflow.com/questions/tagged/laravel-factory
[4] https://laravel.com/api/10.x/Illuminate/Database/Eloquent/Factories/Factory.html
[5] https://laravelversions.com/en/9
[6] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8sNkNOTkEXY
[7] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eS5rxzVIpMI