When comparing the heart rate monitoring accuracy of the Redmi Watch 5 Active and the Apple Watch Ultra, several factors come into play:
Redmi Watch 5 Active
- Accuracy: The Redmi Watch 5 Active generally provides acceptable heart rate readings, especially during resting or low-intensity activities. However, its accuracy can vary, particularly during more intense workouts or when compared to other devices like the OnePlus Watch 2R or Galaxy Fit 3. In some tests, the heart rate was found to be similar to other budget devices like the Galaxy Fit 3 and Xiaomi Smart Band 9[1][5].- Limitations: The watch's step tracking is less accurate compared to heart rate monitoring, which might be a concern for users prioritizing step tracking[1][5].
- Price and Value: Being priced under Rs 3,000, it offers good value for its price, though accuracy may not match more premium devices.
Apple Watch Ultra
- Accuracy: The Apple Watch Ultra is widely regarded as one of the most accurate heart rate trackers available. It provides precise readings, especially when data is recorded and processed through the Apple Health app[2][4]. However, there can be a slight delay in live heart rate readings on the watch screen compared to the recorded data[2].- Advanced Features: It offers advanced features like integration with other Apple devices and apps, which enhances its overall tracking capabilities[4].
- Limitations: Despite its high accuracy, some users have reported occasional inaccuracies, particularly during intense activities[6]. The watch's premium price reflects its advanced features and build quality.
Comparison
- Resting Heart Rate: Both devices can accurately measure resting heart rate, with minimal differences in readings[8][9].- Workout Accuracy: The Apple Watch Ultra generally provides more consistent and accurate heart rate readings during workouts, thanks to its advanced sensors and processing[4][6]. The Redmi Watch 5 Active may not match this level of accuracy, especially in high-intensity activities[5].
- Price and Target Audience: The Apple Watch Ultra is designed for serious fitness enthusiasts and those willing to invest in premium technology, while the Redmi Watch 5 Active is more suited for casual users on a budget.
In summary, while both devices can monitor heart rate effectively, the Apple Watch Ultra offers superior accuracy and features, particularly for intense workouts and integration with other Apple services. The Redmi Watch 5 Active provides good value for its price but may not match the Ultra's performance in all scenarios.
Citations:
[1] https://www.outlookbusiness.com/technology/redmi-watch-5-active-review-quite-possibly-the-best-smartwatch-under-rs-3000
[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UxWa1TiqSxw
[3] https://versus.com/en/apple-watch-ultra-vs-redmi-watch-5
[4] https://www.nextpit.com/apple-watch-ultra-2-review
[5] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u1P6AhCmjL0
[6] https://discussions.apple.com/thread/255007332
[7] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Jvfmb-Vs5Q
[8] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c5RJH7GLERk
[9] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cO7Fbj_0UKI
[10] https://connectthewatts.com/2023/01/30/apple-watch-ultra-wrong/
[11] https://www.aim7.com/blog/smartwatch-wearable-technology-accuracy
[12] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOUsIqp0_M8