When comparing the comfort of the silicone bands between the Garmin Vivoactive 5 and the Redmi Watch 5 Active, several factors come into play:
1. Material and Design: Both watches use silicone bands, which are generally soft and comfortable. However, the comfort can vary based on the specific design and material quality. Garmin's silicone bands are often praised for their durability and comfort, but some users have reported issues with breathability, which can lead to skin irritation over time[1]. In contrast, the Redmi Watch 5 Active also features a silicone strap that is described as comfortable, but there is less specific feedback on its breathability compared to Garmin[5].
2. Breathability and Skin Irritation: Silicone bands can sometimes cause skin irritation due to a lack of breathability. Users of the Garmin Vivosmart series have reported needing to switch arms to allow skin to heal, indicating potential issues with prolonged wear[1]. There is less specific feedback on the Redmi Watch 5 Active regarding skin irritation, but it's generally noted as comfortable.
3. Adjustability and Fit: Both watches offer adjustable bands to fit various wrist sizes. The Garmin Vivoactive 5 has a minimum wrist size of about 125 mm and a maximum of 190 mm, ensuring a secure fit for most users[4]. The Redmi Watch 5 Active also provides a comfortable fit, though specific size ranges are not detailed in the available information.
In summary, while both watches have silicone bands that are generally comfortable, the Garmin Vivoactive 5 might require more attention to breathability and skin comfort due to user reports. The Redmi Watch 5 Active is noted for its comfort but lacks detailed feedback on long-term wear and breathability.
Citations:
[1] https://forums.garmin.com/sports-fitness/healthandwellness/f/vivosmart-5/356521/vivosmart-5-hurts-skin-need-breathable-replacement-band
[2] https://www.tvcmall.com/details/watch-band-for-xiaomi-redmi-watch-5-active-watch-5-lite-huawei-watch-gt-5-46mm-universal-22mm-silicone-strap-black-sku6806010862a.html
[3] https://www.techradar.com/health-fitness/fitness-trackers/garmin-vivoactive-5-review
[4] https://www.bestbuy.com/site/garmin-vivoactive-5-gps-smartwatch-42-mm-fiber-reinforced-polymer-slate-aluminum-and-black/6554489.p?skuId=6554489
[5] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mousBbBBD64
[6] https://versus.com/en/garmin-vivoactive-vs-xiaomi-redmi-watch-5-active
[7] https://strapsco.com/product-category/garmin-vivoactive-5-bands/
[8] https://www.reddit.com/r/smartwatch/comments/1fhjftt/redmi_watch_5_lite_first_impressions/
[9] https://www.reddit.com/r/GarminWatches/comments/1byfga9/really_weird_question_vivoactive_5_vs_redmi_watch/
[10] https://versus.com/en/garmin-vivoactive-5-vs-xiaomi-mi-watch