Home Arrow Icon Knowledge base Arrow Icon Global Arrow Icon What are the key differences between DeepAR in TensorFlow and GluonTS


What are the key differences between DeepAR in TensorFlow and GluonTS


The key differences between DeepAR in TensorFlow and GluonTS are:

1. Implementation Framework:
- DeepAR in TensorFlow: Implemented using TensorFlow, a popular deep learning framework.
- GluonTS: Built on top of the Apache MXNet deep learning framework and uses the Gluon API.

2. Model Components:
- DeepAR in TensorFlow: Includes a Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) with LSTM or GRU cells that takes previous time points and co-variates as input.
- GluonTS: Provides a range of components for building time series models, including neural networks, probabilistic models, and state-space models.

3. Model Development:
- DeepAR in TensorFlow: Focuses on implementing a specific model, DeepAR.
- GluonTS: A comprehensive toolkit for building and benchmarking time series models, including DeepAR and other state-of-the-art models.

4. Usage and Purpose:
- DeepAR in TensorFlow: Primarily used for implementing the DeepAR model.
- GluonTS: Designed for scientists and researchers to rapidly develop and benchmark new time series models for tasks such as forecasting and anomaly detection.

5. Additional Features:
- DeepAR in TensorFlow: Does not include additional features like data I/O, model evaluation, and plotting utilities.
- GluonTS: Includes tools for rapid experimentation, including data I/O, model evaluation, and plotting utilities.

6. Pre-Bundled Models:
- DeepAR in TensorFlow: Does not include pre-bundled models.
- GluonTS: Includes pre-bundled implementations of state-of-the-art time series models, allowing for easy benchmarking of new algorithms.

7. Model Evaluation:
- DeepAR in TensorFlow: Does not include specific tools for model evaluation.
- GluonTS: Includes tools for model evaluation and provides a benchmarking framework.

8. Data Requirements:
- DeepAR in TensorFlow: Does not specify data requirements.
- GluonTS: Supports both univariate and multivariate time series data.

9. Model Choice Criteria:
- DeepAR in TensorFlow: Does not provide specific criteria for choosing between DeepAR and other models.
- GluonTS: Provides criteria similar to those for choosing between Auto-regressive (AR) models and ETS models, recommending DeepAR if there are global effects inherent in the dataset that would improve forecasts for individual time series.

10. Community and Support:
- DeepAR in TensorFlow: Limited community support.
- GluonTS: Actively maintained and used at Amazon, with a growing community and extensive documentation.

In summary, while both DeepAR in TensorFlow and GluonTS are used for time series forecasting, GluonTS is a more comprehensive toolkit that provides a broader range of tools and features for building and benchmarking time series models. GluonTS is designed for scientific use cases and includes pre-bundled models and tools for rapid experimentation, making it a more versatile and widely applicable tool for time series modeling[1][2][3][4][5].

Citations:
[1] https://www.jmlr.org/papers/volume21/19-820/19-820.pdf
[2] https://ar5iv.labs.arxiv.org/html/1906.05264
[3] https://github.com/awslabs/gluonts/discussions/2169
[4] https://github.com/arrigonialberto86/deepar
[5] https://datascience.stackexchange.com/questions/110122/what-is-feat-dynamic-real-feat-static-cat-and-feat-static-real-in-gluonts-model